Saturday 22 Sep, 2018
Welcome to RISCOS.org
Jump to 
Search Articles 
Search for Software 
 

Speed Tests and Comparisons

Note This page is quite out of date now, and awaiting update with newer machines!

One of the most contentious and long-running discussions in the world of computers is the old "My computer is faster than your computer" argument. Whilst a lot of variables come into play when testing computers, this page has been created in order to give a rough indication of 'real world' speed tests.

I've specifically avoiding using industry benchmarks, such as Dhrystone and Whetstone tests etc, as these can often give misleading results, especially when manufacturers may optimise their hardware to 'cheat' at particular well known testing protocols.

If you would like me to perform any specific additional tests, then please let me know and I can add the results to the table below.

Description of test carried outAcorn Risc Kinetic Risc PCCastle IyonixWindowsXP PCApple iMacApple PowerBook
Power up machine from initial switch on to logon prompt.28.7s35.3s from power-up to desktop[1]31.7s1m 8.28s1m 52.53s
Time from entering username/password to reaching a useable desktop environment.25.2s11s18.8s33.09s
Time to shutdown the machine, having quit all applications.<1s<1s11.09s10s11.76s

Graphics comparisons

A quick look at various photo manipulation and graphics speed comparisons.

Example image

As a quick comparison of graphical processing speed, I've performed the following tests on a 600MHz XScale powered Iyonix, a 233MHz Kinetic powered Risc PC and a 1GHz G4 powered Apple Mac. All timings are in seconds.

I used Photodesk Olympic edition on RISC OS and GraphicConverter on Mac OS X.

You can click on the thumbnail image in order to view the original (2048x1536) JPEG image.

Description of test carried outRisc PCIyonixApple PowerBook
Load 669,276 byte JPEG image6.162.511.83
Rotate image by 23° anti-clockwise13.149.092.14
Unsharpen mask using a radius of 12 pixels, 200% contrast boost and a threshold of 2%181.2074.9120.66
Scale to 200 pixels wide (ie. create thumbnail you see here)3.522.264.46

Others
If you would like to see any other machines tested then please contact me.

Machines used for testing

Acorn Risc PC
This is one of the last generation of Acorn computers running RISC OS. The machine under test was a RPC 700 model which has been upgraded to a 233MHz Kinetic processor and has 192MB of RAM fitted. It is installed with RISC OS Select 4.37

Castle Iyonix PC
This is the latest generation of computers running RISC OS. The machine under test was a top-end machine with a 600MHz xScale processor and 512MHz of RAM. It has an nVidia GEForce graphics card and 120GB hard drive.
For more information, visit www.iyonix.com

Windows PC
The machine under test was a 2.6GHz P4 machine fitted with 512MB RAM, 80GB hard drive and running the latest version of WindowsXP home edition with all current updates.
For more information, visit www.novatech.co.uk

Apple iMac
This machine is a 17" iMac running OS X Panther, again with all the latest updates installed. It is powered by a 1GHz G4 processor, has 512MB RAM and an 80GB hard drive.
For more information, visit docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=86227

Apple PowerBook
This machine is a 15" Titanium PowerBook running OS X Panther, again with all the latest updates installed. It is powered by a 500MHz G4 processor, has 384MB RAM and an 20GB hard drive.
For more information, visit docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=43095

Notes
Iyonix power-up - As RISC OS 5 currently doesn't have multi-user capability, the time taken is from power-on to a working desktop environment. This includes an approx. 13s of hardware delay on initial power-on. I'm not sure at present what causes this.

Add a comment to this article

If you wish to add a comment to this article, please use the form below. Please note that by submitting comments using this form you are allowing all of the information submitted to be visible on this website. Your comment will be published immediately, so please proof-read before you add. Any comments deemed to be abusive or irrelevant to the topic of the article may be removed without warning.

Posted by: (optional)

Email or web site: (optional, emails will be mangled to avoid spambots)

Comments: (maximum length 2000 characters)

If you would like to add a URL to another site, please enter the address (without http://) inside square brackets. Use an optional closing curly bracket to add a description. eg. to link to http://www.vigay.com enter [www.vigay.com}Vigay.com]

To prevent spambots, please re-enter the following code:
*****


Email Email this page to a friend

 Last edit: 10th Apr 2016 at 4:57pm (895 days ago)

Bookmark with:What are these?
delicious Deliciousdigg Diggreddit redditfacebook Facebookstumbleupon StumbleUpon

RSS Feed 

^
 
Valid HTML 4.01!
Valid CSS!
Best viewed with a cup of tea Crafted by RISC OS